Google shuts down its Works with Nest program, interrupts access to Nest products for third parties and requires the use of Google Assistant. But Google announced an exception: Alexa will still be able to check Nest hardware.
Google Cuts Third Party Access
Recently, Google announced it would blow its Works with Nest program. Working with Nest allow products from other companies to control Nest your garage door opener could tell the thermostat that you want to look up the heat for example. If a company wanted some kind of integration, it would have to go over with Works with Google Assistant.
This program does not allow direct control of the Nest. instead, you would set up routines to do the job. And another obvious issue arose from the change: Works with Nest skills built for Alexa would not work. And since Alexa is a voice assistant on its own, the jump to Works with Google Assistant renders it out of the question.
Alexa gets a reprieve
Alexa currently uses the Works With Nest to control Nest hardware and websites that The Verge has reported that the Alexa integration ceases to work on August 31, 2019. It is true that Alexa's current Works With Nest based integration will break on that date.
But according to a page on Nest's website discovered by Ars Technica-we are not sure if it was up all the time or if Google uploaded it later, it is not so.
Google says it will work with Amazon to allow Alexa's control over the Nest hardware to come. Google promises to complete the transition before the shutdown and continues to say that all Alexa will keep all of their current Nest integrations.
Smarthomes turns to Walled Gardens
Google works with Amazon is good news for Alexa users. But everyone else who uses Wink Hubs, IFTTT, Yonomi, Lutron and anyone who uses Works With Nest will still lose functionality. Smarthomes work best with open standards. You should be able to buy products from different companies and they should work together.
Alexa seems to have a special exception that other voice assistants, services and companies will not have access to. If the relationship between Google and Amazon goes down again, it can even make it difficult for Alexa to access the Nest.
By blocking access to Nest hardware for most businesses, Google can secure your data, but it also puts the fence around its walled garden. Future voting assistants (and current third-party alternatives like Mycroft) will start to a disadvantage that can be extremely difficult to overcome.
Also established manufacturers of products like Lutron have stated that the features offered under the old Nest program are impossible to support under the new Google Assistant program. When you buy smart home devices, you will ask yourself if it fits within your smart home ecosystem. And if it doesn't, look for the Google device to go to your "Google home".